SASGIS - Доработка карты (ZMP)
View Issue Details
0002460Доработка карты (ZMP)[All Projects] Багpublic16-07-2014 10:5417-07-2014 03:28
gravitystorm 
 
normalmajoralways
newopen 
0002460: Please remove thunderforest.com and opencyclemap.org tileservers
My name is Andy Allan and I run the tileservers at thunderforest.com and opencyclemap.org

Your application SASPlanet has become very popular, and it is downloading too many tiles each day for me to support for free. I realize that this application is open-source, so instead of asking for payments I ask you to please remove all of my tileservers from your configuration.

Предупреждение - автоматический перевод!

Меня зовут Энди Аллан и я запускаю tileservers на thunderforest.com и opencyclemap.org

Ваша заявка SASPlanet стала очень популярной, и он загружает слишком много плитки каждый день для меня, чтобы поддержать бесплатно. Я понимаю, что это приложение с открытым исходным кодом, так что вместо того, чтобы просить платежей прошу вас, пожалуйста, удалите все мои tileservers из конфигурации.
No tags attached.
Issue History
16-07-2014 10:54gravitystormNew Issue
16-07-2014 13:18zedNote Added: 0014422
16-07-2014 13:19zedNote Edited: 0014422bug_revision_view_page.php?bugnote_id=14422#r6161
16-07-2014 13:47vdemidovNote Added: 0014427
16-07-2014 13:59zedProjectSAS.Планета => Доработка карты (ZMP)
16-07-2014 14:07gravitystormNote Added: 0014428
17-07-2014 03:28ParasiteNote Added: 0014440
17-07-2014 03:29ParasiteNote Edited: 0014440bug_revision_view_page.php?bugnote_id=14440#r6171
17-07-2014 03:30ParasiteNote Edited: 0014440bug_revision_view_page.php?bugnote_id=14440#r6172
17-07-2014 03:43ParasiteNote Edited: 0014440bug_revision_view_page.php?bugnote_id=14440#r6173

Notes
(0014422)
zed   
16-07-2014 13:18   
(edited on: 16-07-2014 13:19)
>to support for free
Really free? http://thunderforest.com/pricing/

You can protect your servers as well as it done in maps.google.com or other - ban robots if you can detect them.

(0014427)
vdemidov   
16-07-2014 13:47   
Кстати, а где в наших картах есть thunderforest.com ? А то я не нашел. opencyclemap.org есть, а вот thunderforest.com не видно.
(0014428)
gravitystorm   
16-07-2014 14:07   
thunderforest.com and opencyclemap.org are the same servers - I just mention them both to save any confusion.

If you can remove opencyclemap.org from your application that would be appreciated.
(0014440)
Parasite   
17-07-2014 03:28   
(edited on: 17-07-2014 03:43)
Hola Alan,

at your website you posted, quote: "Using our world-class map styles on your own websites and in your apps".
And then "Hobby Project: Free!", following by "Tiles per month - 150,000"
http://thunderforest.com/pricing/

The first thing is that your server basically is not free, as far as you show the prices to the public. It is only has the limited and restricted free access to the [basically] payable content.

The second thing is that our app is a "Hobby"-level non-profitable project, thus our app entitles for a "Free!" use of your website based on your own frames. The amount of tiles being downloaded is up to the each user, but not the application itself. It is not a user's nor the browser's obligation to sum and count the total amount of tiles - but yours as the content provider, as far as you mentioned that amount at your side (see how Google does the same thing, for example - and they not even show such boundaries anywhere and not even boring the end-users with that, but quietly limiting the download process itself).

In other words - so far I hardly see any juristical issue here, and the decision of your servers removal is fully on our good will. And we will discuss the issue among the colleagues ASAP - just to support your good work and your great project, you know. :)